Loading
Right to Die: The Law of End-of-Life Decisionmaking, Third Edition

Right to Die: The Law of End-of-Life Decisionmaking, Third Edition

SKU:10045752-7777
Alan Meisel, Kathy L. Cerminara, Thaddeus Mason Pope
Format
For general delivery times, please see our shipping policy
Price:
$9,995.00
Product Line
Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory U.S.
Product SKU
10045752-7777
ISBN-13
9780735546653
Availability
Ships in 3-5 Business Days
Publish Frequency
Semi-annually
Last Updated
2026-07-21

Overview

The Right to Die, Third Edition analyzes the statutory and case law surrounding the profound issues of end-of-life decisionmaking. Whether the situation calls for long-term planning or quick, unexpected decisionmaking, this cogent, one source treatise guides you through all the available channels for helping your clients reach the ultimate resolution.

This comprehensive edition guides general practitioners, elder law, health law, and health care professionals through complex issues pertaining to passive and active hastening of death and such subsequent statutes as The Oregon Death with Dignity Act. Also covered in the Third Edition are such issues as:

  • Civil and Criminal liability for such efforts
  • Do-not-resuscitate orders
  • Advance directives
  • Health care powers of attorney
  • Palliative medical care
  • Decisionmaking for children and newborns
  • Surrogate decisionmaking statutes
  • Resolution in a clinical versus a court setting
  • And much more

Note: Online subscriptions are for three-month periods. 

Table Of Contents

Prefaces to Supplements


Preface


Acknowledgments to Supplements


Acknowledgments


Chapter 1A INTRODUCTORY CHAPTER OF NEW DEVELOPMENTS

§1A.01 Overview of 2003-2004 Developments

§1A.02 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2003-2004

§1A.03 Overview of 2004-2005 Developments

§1A.04 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2004-2005

§1A.05 Overview of 2005-2006 Developments

§1A.06 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2005-2006

§1A.07 Overview of 2006-2007 Developments

§1A.08 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2006-2007

§1A.09 Overview of 2007-2008 Developments

§1A.10 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2007-2008

§1A.11 Overview of 2008-2009 Developments

§1A.12 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2008-2009

§1A.13 Overview of 2009-2010 Developments

§1A.14 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2009-2010

§1A.15 Overview of 2010-2011 Developments

§1A.16 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2010-2011

§1A.17 Overview of 2011-2012 Developments

§1A.18 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2011-2012

§1A.19 Overview of 2012-2013 Developments

§1A.20 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2012-2013

§1A.21 Overview of 2013-2014 Developments

§1A.22 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2013-2014

§1A.23 Overview of 2014-2015 Developments

§1A.24 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2014-2015

§1A.25 Overview of 2015-2016 Developments

§1A.26 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2015-2016

§1A.27 Overview of 2016–Mid-2017 Developments

§1A.28 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in 2016–Mid-2017

§1A.29 Overview of Later 2017 Developments

§1A.30 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Later 2017

§1A.31 Overview of Late 2017–Early 2018 Developments

§1A.32 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Late 2017–Early 2018

§1A.33 Overview of Later 2018 Developments

§1A.34 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Later 2018

§1A.35 Overview of Late 2018–Early 2019 Developments

§1A.36 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Late 2018–Early 2019

§1A.37 Overview of Later 2019 Developments

§1A.38 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Later 2019

§1A.39 Overview of Late 2019–Early 2020 Developments

§1A.40 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Late 2019–Early 2020

§1A.41 Overview of Later 2020 Developments

§1A.42 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Later 2020

§1A.43 Overview of Late 2020–Early 2021 Developments

§1A.44 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Late 2020–Early 2021

§1A.45 Overview of Later 2021 Developments

§1A.46 Jurisdiction-by-Jurisdiction Legislative and Judicial Developments in Later 2021


Chapter 1 WHAT IS THE RIGHT TO DIE?

§1.01    Meaning of the Right to Die

§1.02    Purpose of This Treatise

§1.03    Scope of the Topic

§1.04    Existing Practices

§1.05    Public Attitudes

§1.06    Medical Attitudes

§1.07    Legal Antecedents

§1.08    Health Care Terminology

§1.09    Table of Cases and Attorney General Opinions

§1.10    Bibliography


Chapter 2 NATURE AND SOURCES OF THE RIGHT TO DIE

§2.01    Nature and Sources of the Right to Die

§2.02    Legal Consensus About Forgoing Life-Sustaining Treatment

§2.03    The Supreme Court's Decisions

§2.04    Current State of the Law: Competent Patients

§2.05    Current State of the Law: Incompetent Patients

§2.06    Sources of the Law Governing End-of-Life Decisionmaking

§2.07    Bibliography


Chapter 3 THE APPROPRIATE FORUM FOR END-OF-LIFE DECISIONMAKING: COURTS OR CLINICAL SETTINGS?

§3.01    The General Issue: Whether to Go to Court

§3.02    Specific Procedural Issues

§3.03    General Approaches to Decisionmaking

§3.04    Terminology

§3.05    Criteria for Determination of Incompetence

§3.06    Meaning of Incompetence

§3.07    Effect of Incompetence

§3.08    Presumption of Competence

§3.09    Triggering Inquiry into Incompetence

§3.10    Relationship Between Incompetence Determination and Surrogate Designation

§3.11    Choice of Clinical or Judicial Approach to Determining Incompetence and Designating a Surrogate

§3.12    Customary Medical Practice in Determining Incompetence and Designating a Surrogate

§3.13    Legal Status of Clinical Determinations of Incompetence

§3.14    Who Should Initiate Judicial Proceedings?

§3.15    Legal Status of Clinical Designation of a Surrogate

§3.16    Who May Serve as Surrogate?

§3.17    Surrogate's Lack of Decisionmaking Capacity

§3.18    Judicial Review of Decisions About Life-Sustaining Treatment

§3.19    Judicial Review Not Routinely Required

§3.20    Judicial Review Not Required but Permissible

§3.21    Judicial Review Required as a Matter of Course

§3.22    Judicial Review Required in Specific Types of Cases

§3.23    Role of Reviewing Court

§3.24    When Judicial Review Should Be Sought

§3.25    Nonjudicial Review

§3.26    Pros and Cons of Clinical Versus Judicial Decisionmaking

§3.27    Other Procedural Considerations

§3.28    Bibliography


Chapter 4 DECISIONMAKING STANDARDS FOR INCOMPETENT PATIENTS

§4.01    Introduction

§4.02    Substituted Judgment Standard

§4.03    Meaning of “Substituted Judgment”: Subjective or Objective?

§4.04    Application to Never-Competent Patients

§4.05    Subjective Standard

§4.06    States Requiring or Preferring Subjective Standard

§4.07    Best Interests Standard

§4.08    Special Categories of Patients

§4.09    Role of Surrogates

§4.10    Limits on Surrogate's Decisional Authority

§4.11    Preferences of Incompetent Patients

§4.12    Bibliography


Chapter 5 LIMITATIONS ON END-OF-LIFE DECISIONMAKING

§5.01    Introduction

§5.02    Categorical Approach

§5.03    Prognostic Approach

§5.04    Balancing Approach

§5.05    Bibliography


Chapter 6 APPLICATION OF END-OF-LIFE PRINCIPLES TO PARTICULAR TREATMENTS AND ILLNESSES

§6.01    Introduction

§6.02    Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (DNR Orders)

§6.03    Other Forms of Treatment

§6.04    Treatment of Particular Conditions

§6.05    Bibliography


Chapter 7 ADVANCE DIRECTIVES

§7.01    Introduction

§7.02    Validity and Enforceability

§7.03    Relationship Between Advance Directive Statutes and Common Law

§7.04    Uniform Acts and Federal Legislation

§7.05    Requirements for Execution of Statutory Advance Directives

§7.06    Requirements for Implementation

§7.07    Scope of Directive

§7.08    Termination of Directive

§7.09    Special Provisions Relating to Proxy Directives

§7.09A Supported Decision Making

§7.10    Miscellaneous Provisions

§7.10A Implementation of Directives Through Provider Orders

§7.11    Judicial Review

§7.12    Evidentiary Considerations

§7.13    Table of Advance Directive Statutes

§7.14    General Bibliography

§7.15    State-Specific Bibliography


Chapter 8 SURROGATE (FAMILY) DECISIONMAKING STATUTES

§8.01    Introduction

§8.02    Coordination with Advance Directives

§8.03    When Statute Becomes Operative

§8.04    Priority of Persons Who May Serve as Surrogates

§8.05    Unavailability of Potential Surrogate

§8.06    Resolution of Disputes Among Potential Surrogates

§8.07    Scope of Decisionmaking Authority

§8.08    Substantive Standards for Decisionmaking

§8.09    Immunity

§8.10    Table of Surrogate Decisionmaking Statutes

§8.11    Bibliography


Chapter 9 DECISIONMAKING FOR CHILDREN

§9.01    General Principles of Medical Decisionmaking for Children

§9.02    End-of-Life Litigation Involving Children

§9.03    Mature Minors Doctrine in End-of-Life Decisionmaking

§9.04    Substantive Rights: Source and Scope

§9.05    Standards for Decisionmaking by Surrogates

§9.06    Decisionmaking Procedures

§9.07    Bibliography


Chapter 10 DECISIONMAKING FOR HANDICAPPED NEWBORNS

§10.01  Introduction

§10.02  Legal Background

§10.03  Child Abuse Amendments of 1984

§10.04  Nature of Regulatory Scheme

§10.05  Basic Requirement: Provision of Medically Indicated Treatment

§10.06  Exceptions to Basic Requirement: Treatment Not Medically Indicated

§10.07  Enforcement

§10.08  Infant Care Review Committees

§10.09  Relationship of Child Abuse Amendments to State Case Law

§10.10  Relationship of Child Abuse Amendments to State Statutes

§10.11  Effect of Child Abuse Amendments and Regulations

§10.12  EMTALA and ADA

§10.13  Bibliography


Chapter 11 CIVIL LIABILITY

§11.01  Introduction

§11.02  Intentional Torts

§11.03  Torts Sounding in Negligence

§11.04  Other Tort Theories

§11.05  Vicarious Liability

§11.06  Refusal to Pay for Care

§11.07  Contract Claims

§11.08  State Constitutional and Statutory Claims

§11.09  Federal Constitutional and Statutory Remedies

§11.10  Conscientious Objection

§11.11  Immunity from Liability

§11.12  Damages

§11.13  Attorneys' Fees

§11.14  Bibliography


Chapter 12 CRIMINAL LIABILITY: ACTIVELY HASTENING DEATH

§12.01  Introduction

§12.02  Forgoing Treatment and Suicide/Assisted Suicide

§12.03  Forgoing Treatment and Homicide

§12.04  Active Interventions to End Life

§12.05  Constitutionality

§12.06  Aid-in-Dying Statutes

§12.07  Active Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide in Other Countries

§12.08  Future Legal Developments

§12.09  Table of Assisted Suicide Statutes

§12.10  Bibliography


Chapter 13 THE PROBLEM OF “FUTILE” MEDICAL TREATMENT

§13.01  Nature of “Futility Cases”

§13.02  Legal Framing of the Issues

§13.03  Nature of the Debate

§13.04  Meaning of Common Law Right to Self-Determination and Relationship to Futility

§13.05  The Differing Contexts of Conventional End-of-Life and Futility Cases

§13.06  Negative and Positive Rights

§13.07  Legal and Practical Problems with Recognition of a Positive Right to Demand Treatment

§13.08  Privilege to Provide Futile Medical Treatment

§13.08A Privilege to Refuse Futile Medical Treatment

§13.09  The Future of Futility

§13.10  Table of Futility Cases

§13.11  Bibliography

Experts

  • Alan Meisel
    Alan Meisel
    University of Pittsburgh School of Law and School of Medicine
    Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote Professor of Bioethics and Professor of Law
    Alan Meisel is Professor of Law and Bioethics at the University of Pittsburgh. He directs Pitt Law?s Health Law Certificate Program and the Master of
  • Kathy L. Cerminara
    Kathy L. Cerminara
    Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad College of Law
    Professor
    Professor Kathy L. Cerminara?s scholarship focuses on end-of-life decisionmaking and the intersection between end-of-life care, palliative care, and health
  • Thaddeus Mason Pope
    Thaddeus Mason Pope
    Mitchell Hamline School of Law
    Director of the Health Law Institute & Professor of Law
    Thaddeus Mason Pope is Director of the Health Law Institute and Professor of Law and at Mitchell Hamline School of Law. He is also an Adjunct Professor
Loading
Right to Die: The Law of End-of-Life Decisionmaking, Third Edition | Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory