Loading
Hillman on Lawyer Mobility: The Law and Ethics of Partner Withdrawals and Law Firm Breakups, Third Edition

Hillman on Lawyer Mobility: The Law and Ethics of Partner Withdrawals and Law Firm Breakups, Third Edition

SKU:10045617-7777
Robert W. Hillman, Allison Martin Rhodes
Format
For general delivery times, please see our shipping policy
Price:
$3,995.00
Product Line
Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory U.S.
Product SKU
10045617-7777
ISBN-13
9781454872634
Availability
Ships in 3-5 Business Days
Publish Frequency
Annually
Last Updated
2026-08-07

Overview

As lawyers move from one firm to another or from private practice into another sphere -- and as firms restructure to meet increasing economic demands -- numerous ethical, practical, and financial questions arise. Hillman on Lawyer Mobility: The Law and Ethics of Partner Withdrawals and Law Firm Breakups, Third Edition is your definitive guide to this fast developing area of law.


Hillman on Lawyer Mobility analyzes and clarifies all the urgent legal and ethical ramifications in such areas as:


  • The downsizing of law firms
  • Disputes over the existence of a partnership
  • Restrictive covenants
  • Disincentives to competition
  • One-sided fee-sharing agreements
  • Notice of withdrawal
  • Section 42 elections for withdrawing partners
  • Files as property of clients
  • Retaining liens
  • Enforcement of ethics standards through arbitration
  • Collateral consequences of account settlement provisions
  • Compensation for discharged firms
  • Pre-departure solicitation
  • Profit allocation.

Note: Online subscriptions are for three-month periods.

Table Of Contents

1. LAWYER MOBILITY IN PERSPECTIVE

  • The Setting
  • Sources of Restraints on Lawyer Mobility
  • A Vocabulary Primer
  • Changing Perspectives on Loyalty as a Value
  • Identifying the True Costs and Effects of Lawyer Mobility
  • The Future

2. THE ETHICS OF LAWYER MOBILITY

  • Sources of Legal Ethics Law Affecting Lawyer Mobility
    • Historical Perspective and the Model Code of Professional Responsibility
    • Withdrawal Notices under the Model Code
    • In-Person Contacts under the Model Code
    • Modern Ethics Rules Pertinent to Lawyer Mobility
    • Model Rule 1.4, the Duty of Communication
    • Model Rule 1.1, the Duty of Competent Representation
    • Model Rule 5.6, Restrictions on the Right to Practice
    • Model Rule 1.16, Duties to the Client Upon Termination
    • Model Rule 7.3, Solicitation of Client
    • Constitutional Considerations
    • Grabbing as Solicitation
    • Ethics Opinions
    • ABA Formal Ethics Opinions
    • Pennsylvania/Philadelphia Joint Opinion
    • Ethics in Arbitration
    • Discipline and Lawyer Mobility
    • Partners as a Protected Class
    • Mobility Across Jurisdictions and the Unauthorized Practice of Law
    • Practice Pending Admission
  • Client Choice as the Overriding Ethical Issue
    • Client Choice as an Absolute Value
    • The Foundations of Client Choice
    • Limitations on Restrictive Covenants
    • Agreements Discouraging Competition
    • Agreements Not Enforced
    • Disincentives Enforced
    • Concluding Comments on Howard v. Babcock and a Suggested Framework
    • Backdoor Disincentives: One-Sided Fee Sharing
    • Backdoor Obstacles: Confidentiality Agreements
    • Restrictive Covenants as Conditions to the Payment of Retirement Benefits
    • A Preliminary Note on Partnership Payouts
    • Payouts as Competition Subsidies
    • Rationale for Distinguishing Retirement
    • Retirement Trends
    • The Parameters of Retirement
    • A Suggested Framework for Applying the Retirement Benefits Exception
    • Minimum Age and Service Conditions
    • The Existence of Separate Withdrawal Provisions
    • Period Over Which Payments Are Made
    • Availability of Ancillary Benefits
    • The Funding Question
    • A Postscript on Retirement: The Look-Back Issue
    • A Comparative Note: Restrictive Covenants and Protracted Notice Periods Under U.K. Law
    • Client Choice and the Sale of a Law Practice
  • Ethical Issues in Recruiting and Being Recruited
    • Ethical and Contractual Obligations Regarding Confidentiality
    • Conflicts of Interest
    • Personal Interest Conflicts and Recruitment by Opposing Counsel
    • Conflicts With New Firm Clients
    • The Imputation of Conflicts Between Law Firms
    • Avoiding Imputation Through the Hot Potato Doctrine
    • The Restatement
    • Screening
    • Practical Issues in Screening
  • Duties to Clients During Transition
    • Client Communication and ABA 99-414
    • Ethics Rules Regarding Client Notice
    • The Client File as Property
    • In General
    • The Retaining Lien
    • Work Product
    • The Scope of Client Files: The Traditional Ethics Norms and the Digital Dynamic
    • The Scope of the File in the Pre-Digital Era
    • Digital Data and Client Files
    • Beyond Client Files: Firm Property and the Departing Lawyer
    • Post-Departure Email
  • Duties to Clients in the Context of Dissolution
  • Economics of Partner Breakups
    • Fee Splitting
    • Compensation for the Discharged Firm
    • Compensation in the Law Firm Breakup Setting
    • Relationship of Quantum Meruit to Partnership Law's Income-Sharing Principles
    • Law Firm Goodwill
    • Contracting as to Goodwill: Waivers by Departing Partners
    • Contracting as to Goodwill: Anti-Competition Agreements
    • Goodwill as a Firm Asset: Changing Notions of Public Policy

3. TORT, AGENCY, FIRM PROPERTY, AND UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES PERSPECTIVES

  • Tortious Interference with Existing or Prospective Contractual Relations
    • In General
    • Application to Lawyer Mobility
    • Ethics Standards
  • The Loyalty Obligations of Agents
    • Competition by Agents
    • Pre-Withdrawal Competition
  • An Alternative Perspective: The Equal Opportunity to Compete for Clients
  • The Question of Status: Partners Versus Associates
  • Client and Firm Information as a Law Firm's Proprietary Information: The Trade Secrets Perspective
    • In General
    • State Law and Trade Secrets
    • Federal Law and Trade Secrets
    • Application to Law Firms
    • Client Information
    • Beyond Client Lists: Firm Information
  • Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices

4. LAW FIRMS AS PARTNERSHIPS

  • The Uniform Partnership Acts
  • The Threshold Question: Is the Firm a Partnership?
  • Dissolution: Its Meaning and Significance Under the Uniform Partnership Act
    • Dissolution and Partnerships Generally
    • Contracting for Continuity
    • Continuation Agreements
    • Partnership Term Agreements
    • Antidissolution Agreements
    • Agreements to Institutionalize Clients
    • Dissolution and Law Partnerships in Particular
    • Fixed Term Law Partnerships: An Alternative to Restrictive Covenants?
    • Notice of Withdrawal and Determining the Date of Dissolution
    • Section 42 Elections for the Withdrawing Partner
  • Withdrawal Under RUPA: Dissociation and Dissolution
    • Dissolution Restricted
    • Dissociation and Dissolution Under RUPA
    • The RUPA Buyout
    • Liabilities: Effect on Buyout and Indemnification
    • Deferral of Payments
    • Tender and Judicial Valuation
    • Buyouts and Limited Liability Partnerships
    • The RUPA Buyout and the Two-Partner Firm
    • Additional Buyout Difficulties for Law Firm Partnerships
    • Adjusting Payouts to Reflect Effects of Additional Departees
    • Notice of Withdrawal and Determining the Date of Dissociation
    • Compensation for Winding Up Activities
    • Asymmetrical Considerations: RUPA Buyout and Wrongful Dissociation Provisions as Aids for Grabbing and Leaving
  • Collateral Consequences of Account-Settlement Provisions
  • Winding Up a Law Partnership
  • Legal Ethics and the Sharing of Post-Dissolution Income
  • Fiduciary Duties and the Process of Lateral Movement
  • The Obligation to Provide Reasonable Notice of Withdrawal
  • A Note on Lengthy Notice Periods
  • Fiduciary Duties and the Solicitation of Clients
  • Fiduciary Duties and the Recruitment of Staff
  • Client Files
  • Fiduciary Duties and Confidential Information
  • Fiduciary Duties and Payouts to Withdrawing Partners
  • RUPA and Partner Duties
  • Liabilities Asserted After Withdrawal or Dissolution

5. ALTERNATIVES TO PARTNERSHIP: PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONS AND LLCS

  • In General
  • The Birth of the Professional Corporation
  • The Professional Law Corporation as a Partnership: Fox v. Abrams
  • The Limited Liability Company as a Partnership: LaFond v. Sweeney
  • Limitations on Liability
  • Judicial Invalidation of Statutory Limitations on Liability
  • Joint and Several Liability in the Breakup Setting: Professional Corporations
  • Joint and Several Liability in the Breakup Setting: Limited Liability Companies
  • Terminating a Withdrawing Shareholder's Interest in a Law Corporation
  • Fee Splitting

6. LEGAL AND ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS WHEN COMBINING LAW FIRMS

  • Introduction
  • Forms of Combinations
    • An Actual Merger
    • Asset Purchase and Sale Model
    • A Note About De Facto Merger
    • Group Hiring and the Mini-Merger
    • Due Diligence
  • Ethical Issues Associated With Traditional Combinations
    • The Importance of Timing
    • Conflicts of Interest
    • The Hot Potato Doctrine
    • The Practical Problem With Waivers
    • The Sale of Law Practice and Model Rule 1.17
    • Client Consent
    • Confidentiality and Anti-Poaching Agreements
  • Ethical Issues Associated With Alternatives to Full Combination
    • The Of-Counsel Law Firm
    • The Strategic Alliance
    • When Must Conflict Systems Merge
    • Globalization and the Swiss Verein

7. INTEGRATION

  • Introduction
  • Culture
  • Compensation
  • Systems and Practice Management
    • Management Integration
    • Integration and the Lessons from the MeToo Movement
  • Conflict Integration
    • Integration Teams

8. DOWNSIZING THE LAW PARTNERSHIP

  • In General
  • Methods of Downsizing
  • Contractually Based Expulsion
    • In General
    • The Agreement as Predicate to Expulsion
    • Issues That Should Be Addressed in an Expulsion Clause
    • The Good-Faith Standard
    • Good Faith and Cause for Expulsion
    • Good Faith and Bad Cause: Retaliatory Expulsion
    • Good Faith and Bad Cause: Predatory Purpose Expulsions and Financial Gain for Continuing Partners
    • Good Faith and Harsh Consequences of an Expulsion
    • Good Faith and Prior Ameliorative Efforts by the Partnership
    • Process Considerations: Notice, Right to a Hearing, and Statement of Reasons for the Expulsion
    • Notice and Opportunity to Be Heard
    • Statement of Reasons for Expulsion
    • Post-Expulsion Issues
    • The UPA
    • RUPA
  • Noncontractually Based Downsizing
    • Downsizing by Self-Help
    • Downsizing by Decree
    • Decree of Dissolution
    • Decree of Expulsion
  • Noncontractually Based Downsizing as an Alternative to Contractually Based Expulsion

9. THE IMPACT OF LAW FIRM INSOLVENCY ON LAWYER MOBILITY

  • Introduction
  • Winding Up and Law Firms
    • Winding Up/Liquidation Not the Same as Dissolution
    • Various Methods for Winding Up/Liquidation of Law Firm Entities
    • Solvent Winding Up
    • Insolvent Winding Up
    • Bankruptcy Cases—The Basics
    • Bankruptcy Courts and Venue, Generally
    • The Bankruptcy Code and Bankruptcy Cases
    • Authority of the Bankruptcy Estate and Its Representative
  • Law Firms as Debtors Under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code
  • The Estate
  • Clients
  • Litigation by the Law Firm Debtor's Estate Against Partners; Releases
  • Third-Party Claims

10. THE PLANNING PERSPECTIVE: RISK MANAGEMENT IN AN ERA OF BREAKUPS AND LAWYER MOBILITY

  • Developing a Risk Management Strategy
    • The Existing Firm
    • The Acquiring Firm
    • The Mobile Lawyer
  • First Steps in Risk Management for the Law Firm: The Who and the How of Lateral Hiring
  • The Role of the Partnership Agreement
    • The Partnership Agreement as Contract
    • Difficulties of Negotiating and Amending Partnership Agreements
    • Centralized Management as an Agreement-Substitute
    • Policy Statements
    • Past Practices as Agreement Waivers
    • Ethics Norms and Partnership Agreements
    • Enforcement Challenges
  • Select Risk Management Subjects for Partnership Agreements
    • Intellectual Property
    • Departure Process and Restrictions on Payouts
    • Process of Withdrawal
    • Restricting Payouts
    • Lengthening the Payout Period and Establishing Offsets for Breach of a Partnership Agreement
    • Partner Removals and De-Equitizations
    • Winding Up and Antidissolution Provisions
    • Winding Up Provisions
    • Antidissolution Provisions
    • Dispute Resolution
  • Concluding Thought on Risk Management in an Era of Lawyer Mobility

11. CONSTRUCTING AND EXAMINING LAW FIRM PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENTS

  • Introduction
  • Partnership Statutes
  • RUPA and the Partnership Agreement
  • A Hypothetical Partnership Agreement

APPENDICES

  • Appendix: Tie Sheet of 2013 and 1997 Versions of RUPA
  • Appendix A: Generic Due Diligence Checklist Law Firm
  • Appendix B: Risk Management—Lateral Hire Due Diligence Form
  • Appendix C: Loyalty in the Firm—A Statement of General Principles on the Duties of Partners Withdrawing from Law Firms
  • Table of Cases
  • Table of Uniform Partnership Acts
  • Table of Restatements of the Law
  • Table of ABA Ethics Codes
  • Table of Ethics Opinions
  • Index

Experts

  • Robert W. Hillman
    Robert W. Hillman
    University of California, Davis
    FBP Distinguished Professor of Law
    Robert W. Hillman is a leading authority on partnership law and the legal and ethics issues arising from lawyer mobility and law firm breakups. He teaches
  • Allison Martin Rhodes
    Allison Martin Rhodes
    Sheppard Mullin
    General Counsel
    Allison specializes in legal ethics and risk management at Sheppard Mullin.
Loading
Hillman on Lawyer Mobility: The Law and Ethics of Partner Withdrawals and Law Firm Breakups, Third Edition | Wolters Kluwer Legal & Regulatory