1. LAWYER MOBILITY IN PERSPECTIVE
- The Setting
- Sources of Restraints on Lawyer Mobility
- A Vocabulary Primer
- Changing Perspectives on Loyalty as a Value
- Identifying the True Costs and Effects of Lawyer Mobility
- The Future
2. THE ETHICS OF LAWYER MOBILITY
- Sources of Legal Ethics Law Affecting Lawyer Mobility
- Historical Perspective and the Model Code of Professional Responsibility
- Withdrawal Notices under the Model Code
- In-Person Contacts under the Model Code
- Modern Ethics Rules Pertinent to Lawyer Mobility
- Model Rule 1.4, the Duty of Communication
- Model Rule 1.1, the Duty of Competent Representation
- Model Rule 5.6, Restrictions on the Right to Practice
- Model Rule 1.16, Duties to the Client Upon Termination
- Model Rule 7.3, Solicitation of Client
- Constitutional Considerations
- Grabbing as Solicitation
- Ethics Opinions
- ABA Formal Ethics Opinions
- Pennsylvania/Philadelphia Joint Opinion
- Ethics in Arbitration
- Discipline and Lawyer Mobility
- Partners as a Protected Class
- Mobility Across Jurisdictions and the Unauthorized Practice of Law
- Practice Pending Admission
- Client Choice as the Overriding Ethical Issue
- Client Choice as an Absolute Value
- The Foundations of Client Choice
- Limitations on Restrictive Covenants
- Agreements Discouraging Competition
- Agreements Not Enforced
- Disincentives Enforced
- Concluding Comments on Howard v. Babcock and a Suggested Framework
- Backdoor Disincentives: One-Sided Fee Sharing
- Backdoor Obstacles: Confidentiality Agreements
- Restrictive Covenants as Conditions to the Payment of Retirement Benefits
- A Preliminary Note on Partnership Payouts
- Payouts as Competition Subsidies
- Rationale for Distinguishing Retirement
- Retirement Trends
- The Parameters of Retirement
- A Suggested Framework for Applying the Retirement Benefits Exception
- Minimum Age and Service Conditions
- The Existence of Separate Withdrawal Provisions
- Period Over Which Payments Are Made
- Availability of Ancillary Benefits
- The Funding Question
- A Postscript on Retirement: The Look-Back Issue
- A Comparative Note: Restrictive Covenants and Protracted Notice Periods Under U.K. Law
- Client Choice and the Sale of a Law Practice
- Ethical Issues in Recruiting and Being Recruited
- Ethical and Contractual Obligations Regarding Confidentiality
- Conflicts of Interest
- Personal Interest Conflicts and Recruitment by Opposing Counsel
- Conflicts With New Firm Clients
- The Imputation of Conflicts Between Law Firms
- Avoiding Imputation Through the Hot Potato Doctrine
- The Restatement
- Screening
- Practical Issues in Screening
- Duties to Clients During Transition
- Client Communication and ABA 99-414
- Ethics Rules Regarding Client Notice
- The Client File as Property
- In General
- The Retaining Lien
- Work Product
- The Scope of Client Files: The Traditional Ethics Norms and the Digital Dynamic
- The Scope of the File in the Pre-Digital Era
- Digital Data and Client Files
- Beyond Client Files: Firm Property and the Departing Lawyer
- Post-Departure Email
- Duties to Clients in the Context of Dissolution
- Economics of Partner Breakups
- Fee Splitting
- Compensation for the Discharged Firm
- Compensation in the Law Firm Breakup Setting
- Relationship of Quantum Meruit to Partnership Law's Income-Sharing Principles
- Law Firm Goodwill
- Contracting as to Goodwill: Waivers by Departing Partners
- Contracting as to Goodwill: Anti-Competition Agreements
- Goodwill as a Firm Asset: Changing Notions of Public Policy
3. TORT, AGENCY, FIRM PROPERTY, AND UNFAIR TRADE PRACTICES PERSPECTIVES
- Tortious Interference with Existing or Prospective Contractual Relations
- In General
- Application to Lawyer Mobility
- Ethics Standards
- The Loyalty Obligations of Agents
- Competition by Agents
- Pre-Withdrawal Competition
- An Alternative Perspective: The Equal Opportunity to Compete for Clients
- The Question of Status: Partners Versus Associates
- Client and Firm Information as a Law Firm's Proprietary Information: The Trade Secrets Perspective
- In General
- State Law and Trade Secrets
- Federal Law and Trade Secrets
- Application to Law Firms
- Client Information
- Beyond Client Lists: Firm Information
- Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices
4. LAW FIRMS AS PARTNERSHIPS
- The Uniform Partnership Acts
- The Threshold Question: Is the Firm a Partnership?
- Dissolution: Its Meaning and Significance Under the Uniform Partnership Act
- Dissolution and Partnerships Generally
- Contracting for Continuity
- Continuation Agreements
- Partnership Term Agreements
- Antidissolution Agreements
- Agreements to Institutionalize Clients
- Dissolution and Law Partnerships in Particular
- Fixed Term Law Partnerships: An Alternative to Restrictive Covenants?
- Notice of Withdrawal and Determining the Date of Dissolution
- Section 42 Elections for the Withdrawing Partner
- Withdrawal Under RUPA: Dissociation and Dissolution
- Dissolution Restricted
- Dissociation and Dissolution Under RUPA
- The RUPA Buyout
- Liabilities: Effect on Buyout and Indemnification
- Deferral of Payments
- Tender and Judicial Valuation
- Buyouts and Limited Liability Partnerships
- The RUPA Buyout and the Two-Partner Firm
- Additional Buyout Difficulties for Law Firm Partnerships
- Adjusting Payouts to Reflect Effects of Additional Departees
- Notice of Withdrawal and Determining the Date of Dissociation
- Compensation for Winding Up Activities
- Asymmetrical Considerations: RUPA Buyout and Wrongful Dissociation Provisions as Aids for Grabbing and Leaving
- Collateral Consequences of Account-Settlement Provisions
- Winding Up a Law Partnership
- Legal Ethics and the Sharing of Post-Dissolution Income
- Fiduciary Duties and the Process of Lateral Movement
- The Obligation to Provide Reasonable Notice of Withdrawal
- A Note on Lengthy Notice Periods
- Fiduciary Duties and the Solicitation of Clients
- Fiduciary Duties and the Recruitment of Staff
- Client Files
- Fiduciary Duties and Confidential Information
- Fiduciary Duties and Payouts to Withdrawing Partners
- RUPA and Partner Duties
- Liabilities Asserted After Withdrawal or Dissolution
5. ALTERNATIVES TO PARTNERSHIP: PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONS AND LLCS
- In General
- The Birth of the Professional Corporation
- The Professional Law Corporation as a Partnership: Fox v. Abrams
- The Limited Liability Company as a Partnership: LaFond v. Sweeney
- Limitations on Liability
- Judicial Invalidation of Statutory Limitations on Liability
- Joint and Several Liability in the Breakup Setting: Professional Corporations
- Joint and Several Liability in the Breakup Setting: Limited Liability Companies
- Terminating a Withdrawing Shareholder's Interest in a Law Corporation
- Fee Splitting
6. LEGAL AND ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS WHEN COMBINING LAW FIRMS
- Introduction
- Forms of Combinations
- An Actual Merger
- Asset Purchase and Sale Model
- A Note About De Facto Merger
- Group Hiring and the Mini-Merger
- Due Diligence
- Ethical Issues Associated With Traditional Combinations
- The Importance of Timing
- Conflicts of Interest
- The Hot Potato Doctrine
- The Practical Problem With Waivers
- The Sale of Law Practice and Model Rule 1.17
- Client Consent
- Confidentiality and Anti-Poaching Agreements
- Ethical Issues Associated With Alternatives to Full Combination
- The Of-Counsel Law Firm
- The Strategic Alliance
- When Must Conflict Systems Merge
- Globalization and the Swiss Verein
7. INTEGRATION
- Introduction
- Culture
- Compensation
- Systems and Practice Management
- Management Integration
- Integration and the Lessons from the MeToo Movement
- Conflict Integration
8. DOWNSIZING THE LAW PARTNERSHIP
- In General
- Methods of Downsizing
- Contractually Based Expulsion
- In General
- The Agreement as Predicate to Expulsion
- Issues That Should Be Addressed in an Expulsion Clause
- The Good-Faith Standard
- Good Faith and Cause for Expulsion
- Good Faith and Bad Cause: Retaliatory Expulsion
- Good Faith and Bad Cause: Predatory Purpose Expulsions and Financial Gain for Continuing Partners
- Good Faith and Harsh Consequences of an Expulsion
- Good Faith and Prior Ameliorative Efforts by the Partnership
- Process Considerations: Notice, Right to a Hearing, and Statement of Reasons for the Expulsion
- Notice and Opportunity to Be Heard
- Statement of Reasons for Expulsion
- Post-Expulsion Issues
- The UPA
- RUPA
- Noncontractually Based Downsizing
- Downsizing by Self-Help
- Downsizing by Decree
- Decree of Dissolution
- Decree of Expulsion
- Noncontractually Based Downsizing as an Alternative to Contractually Based Expulsion
9. THE IMPACT OF LAW FIRM INSOLVENCY ON LAWYER MOBILITY
- Introduction
- Winding Up and Law Firms
- Winding Up/Liquidation Not the Same as Dissolution
- Various Methods for Winding Up/Liquidation of Law Firm Entities
- Solvent Winding Up
- Insolvent Winding Up
- Bankruptcy Cases—The Basics
- Bankruptcy Courts and Venue, Generally
- The Bankruptcy Code and Bankruptcy Cases
- Authority of the Bankruptcy Estate and Its Representative
- Law Firms as Debtors Under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code
- The Estate
- Clients
- Litigation by the Law Firm Debtor's Estate Against Partners; Releases
- Third-Party Claims
10. THE PLANNING PERSPECTIVE: RISK MANAGEMENT IN AN ERA OF BREAKUPS AND LAWYER MOBILITY
- Developing a Risk Management Strategy
- The Existing Firm
- The Acquiring Firm
- The Mobile Lawyer
- First Steps in Risk Management for the Law Firm: The Who and the How of Lateral Hiring
- The Role of the Partnership Agreement
- The Partnership Agreement as Contract
- Difficulties of Negotiating and Amending Partnership Agreements
- Centralized Management as an Agreement-Substitute
- Policy Statements
- Past Practices as Agreement Waivers
- Ethics Norms and Partnership Agreements
- Enforcement Challenges
- Select Risk Management Subjects for Partnership Agreements
- Intellectual Property
- Departure Process and Restrictions on Payouts
- Process of Withdrawal
- Restricting Payouts
- Lengthening the Payout Period and Establishing Offsets for Breach of a Partnership Agreement
- Partner Removals and De-Equitizations
- Winding Up and Antidissolution Provisions
- Winding Up Provisions
- Antidissolution Provisions
- Dispute Resolution
- Concluding Thought on Risk Management in an Era of Lawyer Mobility
11. CONSTRUCTING AND EXAMINING LAW FIRM PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENTS
- Introduction
- Partnership Statutes
- RUPA and the Partnership Agreement
- A Hypothetical Partnership Agreement
APPENDICES
- Appendix: Tie Sheet of 2013 and 1997 Versions of RUPA
- Appendix A: Generic Due Diligence Checklist Law Firm
- Appendix B: Risk Management—Lateral Hire Due Diligence Form
- Appendix C: Loyalty in the Firm—A Statement of General Principles on the Duties of Partners Withdrawing from Law Firms
- Table of Cases
- Table of Uniform Partnership Acts
- Table of Restatements of the Law
- Table of ABA Ethics Codes
- Table of Ethics Opinions
- Index